• April 9, 2023, 9:13 p.m.

    This is the terms of service that the site intends to adopt. Open for comment for the moment. Once adopted, all members will need to agree to continue using site. (Company name obfuscated to avoid being gazumped for registration)

    Terms of service

    This document contains the provisions which determine the rights and responsibilities of you, the service user and xxx xxxxxx Foundation Ltd, the service provider.

    Permission to use the site

    DPRevived.com ("the Site") is a Web site owned and operated by xxx xxxxxx Foundation (“the Foundation”), a company incorporated in England and limited by guarantee. The Foundation grants permission to you to use this site subject to your acceptance of these terms. By accessing, registering a user name, logging-in or posting content on the site you give your acceptance of these terms.

    Conditions of use

    Your permission to use the Site and its facilities is subject to these conditions:

    Your usage must comply with the standards of acceptable use and content explained below.

    If the Foundation directly contacts you to say that its permission to use the Site has been withdrawn you must cease all usage. The Foundation reserves the right to withdraw permission to us the Site for any reason without explanation.

    You must be of age and standing to enter into a legal agreement under the laws of England.

    Acceptable use

    You must not engage in any activity on the Site which is contrary to the federal
    laws of the United States of America or the laws of the European Union or the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland.

    You must not use or attempt to use another person’s account without their express permission, nor must you impersonate other people when using the forum.

    You may not upload any material to the Site in breach of the owner’s copyright, nor remove any marks showing proprietary ownership from any uploaded materials.

    You may not link or show any part of the site containing members’ copyright materials to other websites in a manner that causes those materials to be separated from the context of The Site without the members' express permission in writing.

    You may not use automated means to access the Site for the purpose of ‘web crawling’ or copying material on the site, unless it is for the purposes of a publicly available search engine or similar resource.

    You may not falsely claim or imply affiliation with or endorsement by the Foundation or the Site.

    You may not circumvent, disable or avoid any security or access restrictions of the Site.

    You may not conduct trade in user names or other unique identifiers on the Site.

    You may not use the Site for advertising, chain letters or other solicitations, nor to gather personal data for these purposes.

    You may not encourage or aid anyone else to violate these terms.

    Content standards

    You may not post or upload any material which is illegal in the jurisdictions of the federal United States of America, the European Union or the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland.

    You may not post or upload content which is liable to cause harm or distress to other people, including personal abuse and offensive discourse targeting a group or an individual based on inherent characteristics (such as race, religion or gender) and that might threaten social peace.

    You may not post or upload material containing malicious computer programs or codes intended to activate such programs or that provides them with data.

    You may not use the Site to disclose information that you do not have the right to disclose.

    Your content

    Nothing in these terms gives the Foundation any ownership rights in any images or other intellectual property that you upload or share using the Site. This includes your account information, posts, images or other content that you submit to the Site. Likewise, nothing in these terms gives you rights over the Foundation’s intellectual property.

    Between yourself and the Foundation, you are solely responsible for any content that you upload or post to the Site. You agree that you will not falsely imply that content that you upload or post is in any way approved by the Foundation or sponsored by it. You agree that the Foundation has no obligation to store, maintain, or provide copies of material that you submit, nor to modify it in order that it complies with these terms.

    Ownership of content uploaded or posted by you remains with you. You decide on the permissions that you grant to other users with respect to it. But at a minimum you licence the Foundation to use it in a manner necessary for the running of the Site. This licence includes the right for the Foundation to copy, publish and analyse any and all content that you submit to the Site and to modify the content in order that it be compatible with the operation of the site, these conditions and any other policies which may be adopted by the Foundation.

    Your responsibilities

    You agree to indemnify the Foundation from any legal claims by others that may be a consequence of any breach by you of these terms, or by such breach of others using your account with your permission. Both you and the Foundation agree to notify the other of any legal claims to which the above applies as soon as possible. If either party fails to notify the other promptly the other party will not have to indemnify the first party for damages the could have been defended against had prompt notice been given.You agree that the Foundation will control investigation, defence and legal claims for which you would have to indemnify the Foundation, and to co-operate with those efforts. The Foundation agrees not to agree to any settlement that admits fault for you or imposes obligations on you without your prior agreement.

    Your account

    You must create and log on to a personal account in order to use some of the facilities of the Site.

    To create such an account you must provide sufficient information about yourself to allow the Foundation to protect the site against impersonation, ‘bot’ accounts and other malicious use. As a minimum, if you create an account you agree to provide a valid e-mail address, which you will regularly monitor. You agree that you will keep that email address up to date.

    Disclaimer

    You accept all risk of using the site and the content thereon. As far as the law allows, the Foundation, its associates and members provide the Site as is, without any warranty whatsoever.

    In the case that the site hyperlinks and integrates services not controlled by the Foundation it does not make any warranty concerning those services or the content that they provide. Use of such services may be governed by other terms between you and those responsible for the service.

    Limits on liability

    Neither the Foundation nor its suppliers will be liable for breach of contract damages that their personnel could not reasonably foreseen when you agreed to these terms. As far as the law allows the total liability to you for claims that are related to any activity of the Foundation are limited to £50 Sterling.

    Enforcement

    The Foundation may investigate violations of these terms and prosecute to the fullest legal extent. The Foundation may notify and assist law enforcement authorities in prosecuting violations of the law and these terms.

    The Foundation reserves the right to modify, redact, and delete content on the site for any reason.

    Changes

    The Foundation adopted these terms on --/--/-- and may subsequently update them. All updates will be posted on the Site. Once a notice of updates has been posted you must agree to the new terms in order to continue using the site, and by so doing give your assent to the new terms.

    Severability
    In the event that any part of this agreement is found to be invalid or unenforceable, only that particular part so found will be inoperative, and not the entire agreement.

    Jurisdiction and disputes

    This Agreement shall be governed by English law. You and the Foundation agree to seek any legal redress related to these terms only in the courts of England. Any dispute arising out of or in connection with this Agreement shall be referred to arbitration in London in accordance with the Arbitration Act 1996 and any amendment thereto or substitution thereof. You agree that arbitration proceedings will be held at the London Court of International Arbitration.

  • bookmark_border

    Thread has been pinned locally.

  • bookmark

    Thread has been pinned globally.

  • Members 14 posts
    April 9, 2023, 9:46 p.m.

    “ You may not link or show any part of the site on other websites which contains members’ copyright materials without their express permission in writing.”

    Could you define or flesh this out a little more. It seems to suggest that a link to any material in this site used as a citation would be prohibited without written permission. Using posts seen on this site which contain links to other sites as an example, any link to pages on DPR that includes text is a link to copyrighted material per their legals, and I doubt anyone here is getting written permission from Amazon or whoever.
    www.dpreview.com/misc/termsandconditions
    That link, attributed and used strictly as a reference, contains copyrighted material.

  • Members 142 posts
    April 9, 2023, 9:56 p.m.

    You may not upload any material to the forum in breach of the owner’s copyright, nor remove any marks showing proprietary ownership from any uploaded materials.
    Add "without permission"? Context is edit and reposting of images.

    You may not link or show any part of the site on other websites which contains members’ copyright materials without their express permission in writing.
    This refers to embedded links to e.g. images and not hyperlinks, right?

    You may not post or upload content which is liable to cause harm or distress to other people, including personal abuse and discriminatory material or ‘hate speech’.
    Perhaps "likely" in place of "liable"

  • Members 369 posts
    April 9, 2023, 11:23 p.m.

    Bob, a big "Thank you!" to you, Alan, and all others who volunteered their input and services in the creation of these terms of service. It's an impressive accomplishment to go from 0 to 3,000-plus members in what seems the blink of an eye. With the "Terms of Service" nearly ready, DPRevived is on the cusp of a new phase of growth. Congratulations!

    I've shared a few questions and observations in-line, below. I've also indicated possible typos or grammar issues in bold within the quoted text. Obviouisly, feel free to use or not this input, as you and the admin team see fit.

    Best regards,
    Bill Ferris
    Flagstaff, AZ USA

    Presumably, agreeing to the "Terms of Service" equates to entering into a legal agreement under English law. Is that correct? Does English law specify what the age of standing is? 18? 21? some other threshold age?

    Presumably, posting a link to the dprevived.com landing page would not be considered a breach, correct? Would posting a link on another site to a DPRevived member post that includes a photo made by the member be a violation? I'm asking for clarification purposes.

    Bearing in mind that I speak and read American English, would the following be more grammatically correct? "You may not link or show any part of the site containing members’ copyright materials to other websites without the members' express permission in writing."

    I have a question about a member's rights and ownership of the original content they upload. I'll ask it within the context of a statement made, below.

    In light of the above statements about a member's posts [text] being the member's property, should a clause be added to the above language laying the groundwork for the Foundation to have the right to edit or delete posts made by members? Is there language elsewhere in the TOS establishing that groundwork?

  • Members 510 posts
    April 10, 2023, 1:22 a.m.

    I also find the "not link" part confusing.Surly you don't try to forbid links to this site (you can't and why would you want to?). Are you possibly referring to displaying content from here on another site? Like hotlinking images or showing a page from here in an iframe or frame?

  • Members 417 posts
    April 10, 2023, 3:40 a.m.

    2 points. First the linking issue needs to be sorted out. Just as an example, someone may send an email extolling the wonderful images of member X Y Z on DPRevived and wishing to enter the link. The terms of service appears to not allow it. I'm sure you can figure something out.

    Second, the sentence, "You may not post or upload content which is liable to cause harm or distress to other people, including personal abuse and discriminatory material or ‘hate speech’." That is a great sentence. However, you never know who will be potentially offended by an image and therefore cause them "distress." This is a worldwide forum and there may be cultural issues one may not be aware of. Perhaps consider expanding upon this a little, perhaps giving a disclaimer?

    Lastly I will leave the "legalize" to others. Just another question. Will the Terms of Service be all the new member will agree to? Are the Terms of Service in lieu of a member code of conduct? Or are the terms the code of conduct?

    Bob

  • Members 284 posts
    April 10, 2023, 3:52 a.m.

    It would be great if people could just reply without the need to "copy and paste" the whole original posts. Makes the threads painfully long to scroll and there is no thread/flat view option.

  • Members 535 posts
    April 10, 2023, 6:41 a.m.

    Great job thanks!

    Two cents from where I sit ...
    ... as I see this meeting space intended as a planetary site (all cultures converge on similar meeting squares)

    For a wider understanding of the rules refrain from using British wherever possible favoring International English. ( I know, this paper part it's legalese )

    A laic note about avoiding "religions and creeds discussions" may be a nice addition to protect everybody's freedom of speech.

  • Members 46 posts
    April 10, 2023, 7:19 a.m.

    I'm thinking that the matter of intent is important. A distinction can be made between an accident vs. a calculated provocation. We can't read minds of course but toxic patterns of behavior eventually become clear. The heavy handedness of some dpr moderators that has been reported here comes to mind as a caution against a reflexive exclusion of a member upon their first offense.

  • April 10, 2023, 7:55 a.m.

    Good point. I'll think about a form of words which protects peoples' copyright without constraining links. The intention is to prohibit hot linking, not linking the page as a whole.
    Edit: New wording added, check to see if it suits.

  • April 10, 2023, 7:58 a.m.

    It's covered, because if you have the owners permission you are not in breach of copyright.

    Refers really to hot linking
    Edit: Check new wording.

    I prefer 'liable' - it has a good correlation with 'liability'.

  • Members 209 posts
    April 10, 2023, 8:23 a.m.

    I think the clause is aimed at preventing [deep]linking to copyrighted materials, but as it apparently leads to discussion, it might need clarification. Note that most here will think of images in this context, but it goes for text as well.

    About that sentence:

    • I think a slightly different word order might be clearer:
      On other websites You may not link to or show any part of the site which contains members’ copyright materials without their express permission in writing.

    • I'd avoid if possible the plural [inclusive?]:
      On other websites You may not link to or show any part of the site which contains any member’s copyright materials without that member's express permission in writing.

  • April 10, 2023, 8:23 a.m.

    Lots of ages of standing but in English law, and the rest of the UK, but to enter into contracts you need to be 18 or older. This doesn't prevent youngsters participating, but their account has to be opened by an adult and then used with that adults express permission. This is worthwhile putting into the next document, which will be guidelines to acceptable use and content standards, which will say how we will interpret the basic terms of service.

    Yes, that's better, but needs to be amended in any case to be specific about hot-linking.
    Edit: your wording adopted.

    Isn't that the statement 'The Foundation reserves the right to modify, redact, and delete content on the site for any reason.' or maybe I should add 'including content that you have uploaded or posted'
    Edit: Added to 'and to modify the content in order that it be compatible with the operation of the site, these conditions and any other policies which may be adopted by the Foundation.

    Thanks for the comments Bill, greatly appreciated

  • April 10, 2023, 8:23 a.m.

    It's hot-linking. I'll amend to clarify.
    Edit. New wording adopted.

  • April 10, 2023, 8:29 a.m.

    Yes, I will amend to make sure that it is clear that it is hot-linking that is referred to.
    Edit: check new wording.

    This is a legal document, gives us the ability to take action should it be needed. The judgment call of when we need to take action is a different matter. The next document will be a clarification with examples of what we would think might fall the wrong side. And of course, people will come up with types of bad behaviour that we never thought of.

    Yes, there will be a another document which will be 'guidelines' which will talk about what would be considered to be in violation of these terms. I hesitate to call it a 'code of conduct', because this is primarily a leisure space for people, not a professional association. It's really guidelines about civil social interaction.

  • April 10, 2023, 8:36 a.m.

    For a Brit, English comes naturally. For an American it would be American English. I'm not sure that there is an authoritative definition of 'International English'. By and large it comes down to a few 'u's here and there and the odd 'z' or 's'.

    I think that has its place in the guidelines, but not in the legal document underpinning them.

  • Members 510 posts
    April 10, 2023, 8:47 a.m.

    I think you should spell it out. Something like "use content on this domain on another site by embedding or framing it, such as embedding images on this domain (hotlinking), or frame our otherwise embed pages or images on this domain". But make better English of it! 😉

    Talking about ESL, I'm afraid I will never read all of that TOS in detail, or in any case I won't understand all of it. Too posh English for me to grasp everything without help. A large part of users here aren't native English speakers. I understand it's a legal document of sort, but maybe a shorted down version (called something other than TOS) for users that puts the essential bits in more everyday English and refers to the TOS. You could call it "Acceptable conduct" or similar.

  • April 10, 2023, 8:48 a.m.

    Remember, this legal part is the underpinning. Unfortunately, it might be necessary, for the health of the site, to exclude people who do these things without intention - sad but true. This documents says that we can. There will be a guidelines document to go with it, which will be a policy document laying out how we are liable to interpret it. And just like the law, the fact that you can be prosecuted doesn't mean that you will be or should be, it just means that there is the legal basis to do it if necessary. In addition, there will be a guidelines for facilitators (aka moderators) which aims to have even standards of application. This will be a public document - absolutely no reason fro it to be private, we're all in this together.