I like both - they're different images, and each has its own vibe. Curiously one seems to be reversed, judging from the cleft in the tree and the shape of the background hills.
Nice. The yellow colours in the emeging leaves make a great contrast with the wintery peaks. I know we're encouraged to include 'foreground interest' but I think in this case I could do without the fence.
The semi-abstract travertine terraces is just my kind of image 😁
Yep, it does look cold,down there on the coast, but the colours warm the heart.
You have some great colours here in this image. Gentle pastels in the sky and even the snow is taking on a slightly similar tone.
Peaceful mood.
Loads of detail in this pano!
You can see how the volcano really dominates the surrounding mountains.
The colours in the sky and the contrast in the water are nicely captured.
Could be printed big and hung in a hallway.
"The Spirit Of Endurance" sounds about right, if it is still going strong today,... after being captured for the famous photo all those years ago!
As Woodsider said, two different photos and both good!
In your B&W version it really did look convincingly like snow!
Getting up close to trees like you did here, and looking straight up gives a "weird" perspective feeling that is quite popular with a general audience.
Here's a shot with a similar perspective feeling and real snow ;-)
I do have a wider view of this but I prefer the tree larger in the image for this one. I also have one cropped similar to the original. There is another tree just to the left of this one which sort of spoils the wider view.
As far as the photo I linked to, it is indeed reversed for some reason. I have seen three original prints from this negative (I don't know who they were printed by) and one was reversed like this and the other two were correct. One was in the Art Gallery of South Australia. I also have a book on Harold Cazneaux and it has this image in it correct way around.