• Members 1517 posts
    July 28, 2023, 8:06 a.m.

    It's such a massive thing and as it can be seen from almost anywhere, then a series is probably the best choice. A range of angles is what you have. Those with clouds that are big and bold enough to counter the presence of the Shard appeal to me. Probably that's because I don't like the thing.
    Maybe that's why I like two the best. It has the clouds. It has something of old London (including low level, horizontal lines and arches that are totally opposite to the thing. We have few humans. Nice to see them in this context. Then we have reminders of the engineering required. Best of all, the Shard doesn't look real here. It resembles an artist's rendition for the planning stages. A warning of what is coming.
    No3 baffles me. what is the tower to the left? I can't see it in the other pictures. Whatever it is, it must be hidden in those shots. Looking at the big glass face of the building on the right of 2, I think that the slim tower must be behind The Shard in 1??? Possibly it is the wa lens and low angle that make the column appear to be so tall?From the sky, I think 3 must have been taken on a different day.
    Re 5. Could the clouds be darkened a little to match them to 1,2 and 4? The positioning of the Shard so it thrusts up through the rent in the roofline makes a statement. As do the railings that are more or less horizontal and their pedestrian connection to the lower level buildings.
    Still, The Shard is a welcome relief from London Bridge and I note how careful you were to keep it out of the shots.

  • Members 1517 posts
    July 28, 2023, 8:50 a.m.

    A pleasure. It's another of those Saturday Evening Post type scenes that gives a peep at the soul of the USA at it's best.
    A folksy, woodsy comfortable room. The wine glasses say it has been a pleasant, low key meeting. An interaction between generations around something technical (and I noted the old bit of intergenerational technology through the window behind Dad's chair. Dad's concentration from the eyes to the poised arm is caught. The assumed son waits patiently, chair pulled back a little from the table. The empty chairs are a nice touch. This is about Dad and Son but there are other members in this family.
    The charcoal drawing effect is a good choice. It's a statement about time as well.
    Michael Moore?

  • Members 1662 posts
    July 28, 2023, 8:54 a.m.

    Thanks for your interesting thoughts. Fascinating that you were a drum scan operator. We've had one in the company I was working years ago, but I wasn't interested in photography at the time... Now I would love to know more about them. Do they have lenses in them? And if so, do you know who manufactures them?

    I'm glad you found a great lens in the 110/2 and am looking forward to more of your results with it. I agree that sharpness/detail can be lots of fun in and of itself. Which adapted Zeiss lenses do you mean btw.?

    I also agree that sharpness isn't necessary for everything. For example: I tried to take this shot with one of the sharpest lenses (a scanner lens by Nikon) I own and then with a 90 year old uncoated Zeiss lens. I clearly preferred the look of the latter, despite the clear lack of sharpness:

    live.staticflickr.com/65535/52738318363_00e864d8ec_b.jpg
    Hard to be soft in a good way...
    by simple.joy, on Flickr

  • Members 1517 posts
    July 28, 2023, 12:37 p.m.

    The magenta against the blue gives heaps of impact. After that, I'm at a loss. This image simply doesn't trigger responses from me or give me anything I can begin to analyze constructively.
    Let's see what you conjure up next week.

  • Members 1517 posts
    July 28, 2023, 12:47 p.m.

    Rolling back through the shots I came across the simplejoy version again and once more I was laughing.
    Look at the number of live things in the photo that seem to be looking at the purple cow. Others seem to be deliberately distancing from it. This may be a photo of considerable value to sociologists.
    Any chance that a purple cow might turn into a swan or butterfly?

  • Members 945 posts
    July 28, 2023, 12:57 p.m.

    The purple cows make the milk for delicious chocolate since 1972
    Here's the full story,...
    chocolatemarketaudit.wordpress.com/2018/10/26/the-story-of-a-purple-cow-milka/

  • Members 762 posts
    July 28, 2023, 1:35 p.m.

    Drum scanner optics were essentially microscope objectives. But not in necessarily recognizable "standard" mounts.

    Adapted lenses on the GFX 100s - Zeiss Milvus 135/2, Nikkor 180/2.8, SMC Pentax-A 645 Macro 120/4 (at 1:1 for "scanning" transparencies and negatives).

    Rich

  • Members 676 posts
    July 28, 2023, 4:39 p.m.

    Thank you all for your kind comments .... much appreciated ...

    I enjoy doing "Street" but COVID and personal problems has me out of practice for the even small amount of practice I use to get. Also, not living in a large city where such photography is experienced more can also be a problem and limitation. ...

    About the picture .. This is taken in a Tavern that has a beer garden seen in the background .. Beers from all over the world and a separate whiskey bar are found here .... Great Chicago Dogs and Kolsh at a table outside is often my lunch ...However, some recent problems with vertigo has my wife restricting me to water, as she thinks I have enough balance problems without adding to them with one beer!!! ....

    Water comes in a regular glass so the one seen on the table is a beer glass .... There is a regular group that meets for lunch at that table so I assume these two are the last of the group to settle up and leave. Their relationship is unknown to me ...

    The technique is left over from my childhood when my mother regularly got the Saturday Evening Post and I saw and admired many of Norman Rockwell's works .. A few years ago a Norman Rockwell exhibit was seen at the local Art Museum and I did a series of photographs there and developed this look emulating his for that series .. I like the results and think it gives my street people a bit of anonymity so I have kept it .....

    More than you ever wanted to know!!! ..

    WhyNot

  • Members 523 posts
    July 28, 2023, 4:55 p.m.

    No, not more than...I'm very interested to learn your personal story and the photo's story, and especially about Norman Rockwell being your influence. Thanks much!

  • Members 523 posts
    July 28, 2023, 5:08 p.m.

    From my personal perspective, the impact of each is lessened when shown together.

    The pp on the first reminds me of the solarization filter in Nik Color Efex. I'm not in love with the clouds (if that is what we're seeing), but the rest is fascinating and attention grabbing for the light-dark, repeating patterns, and details.

    The second composition overwhelms my aging brain. A photo of mostly the ceiling, and a separate photo of mostly the shadows and light of the walkway become two high-impact photos. The architecture of the ceiling is gorgeous and your position great for that feeling of its going on a long distance. The angled shadows on the floor are a pleasing ordered geometry, with the columns and a glimpse of ceiling leading us all the way in.

  • Members 1333 posts
    July 28, 2023, 5:13 p.m.

    I just saw this photo op coming and having only few seconds, took aim, framed and pressed shutter.

  • Members 523 posts
    July 28, 2023, 5:47 p.m.

    Thanks! I appreciate your keen eye and instincts.

    When I was regularly driving around the countryside in search of photo ops, especially raptors and other wildlife, I would get quite an adrenalin rush from "having only a few seconds" - 😁

  • Members 544 posts
    July 28, 2023, 8:26 p.m.

    Looking at the small version, I thought the filter was applied to the reflection of you, but not to Stella, the cat, or the window frame, which I thoiught was rather cool. On looking at the full size image, I was disappointed to find that was not so, but maybe that would be an idea to try?
    In any case I think the filter works very well here and I like the resulting image very much. It shrouds you and the reflected world in mystery, but the cat is clear and straightforward, even with the filter, and her look underlines that feeling.
    As to using filters or not, I am open to them. They are just another tool to change the original, like cloning, changing the lighting or colour, converting to B&W etc. etc. So like all PP, I can only judge the result, which can enhance or ruin an image.

    Pete

  • Members 544 posts
    July 28, 2023, 8:35 p.m.

    Again, an unusual composition outside the norms makes us stop and think, and the negative space of the sky means we should look at the roof, even if it is at the bottom of the frame. It is quickly identifiable as a house, but the crop is so severe, we should obviously look at it as just a roof or, more likely, a geometrical study - a pattern. The geometric shapes have enough irregularity and there is enough texture to keep the viewer interested, and the complementary blues, yellows, greys and blue-greens are very harmonious.
    It is an unusual image, which attracts and rewards attention.

    Pete

  • Members 544 posts
    July 28, 2023, 8:44 p.m.

    Now this is a beauty. It is a very good study of a heron, with a perfect reflection in the water.
    When the reflection is that good, you really do get almost the same above and below the horizon line of the reflection, so where to put that line? Personally, I find an exact symmetry between the object and its reflection a bit boring, and would usually choose to show more of the reflection than the real world, as you have done, because it is less usual. The information about the background and the heron's environment is there anyway, but in the reflection.

    Pete

  • Members 544 posts
    July 28, 2023, 8:50 p.m.

    This looks like a great place to visit, and your photo does it justice.
    I like the rocks and overhang on the left to give a foreground, leading to the middleground of the waterfall and outcrop and onto the distant countryside. This creates a nice feeling of depth. The exposure and colours are good and the people give scale. You seem to have ticked all the boxes!

    Pete

  • Members 544 posts
    July 28, 2023, 9:04 p.m.

    The processing certainly makes this image stand out and makes the viewer stop and think about the story or message being told, or whether it is simply supposed to be pretty. The bright pink highlights the trees in no uncertain terms, so they are no doubt the main subject, at least below the sky. The rest is man made road, concrete walls and buildings and vehicles, so they take on a lesser role or even that of the opposition. The wall across the frame hinders the viewer's eye from moving freely into the frame, but the call of those pink trees is stronger.
    So I interpret this as a struggle between man made objects and nature. But maybe it is just supposed to be eye-candy, which would be a shame.

    Pete

  • Members 544 posts
    July 28, 2023, 9:19 p.m.

    The processing is unusual, like a black and white oil painting, so I was interested to read the story behind it. The effect works well in this image.
    The younger man is partly covered by a chair and his clothes blend in with the surroundings but he is looking at the older man, who is obviously the main subject. We see him clearly and his brighter clothes helps him stand out. He is totally engrossed in the action of paying the bill and, maybe, concentrating on the challenges. Is the bill correct? Why won't it accept the card? Have I got my PIN correct? Has the signal failed or did the transaction go through? How much should I tip? Should it be for the quality of the food or the efficiency and friendliness of the waiter/waitress? Maybe service is included, but do I care? Yes we have all been there and recognise it on our main character, which endears him to us.
    It is an everyfay situation, but well seen and presented.

    Pete