• Members 162 posts
    Oct. 11, 2024, 7:28 p.m.

    We often see Zone V equated to Middle Gray but is rarely mentioned that there are other shades of gray within the Zone.

    I was quite pleased today to find this illustration:

    zones showing no. in the middle.jpg

    It is clear that middle gray (generally agreed to be 18%) is indeed in the middle of Zone V, but I had to know what is the range of reflectance represented by Zone V ?!

    I asked AI:- it said "12% to 24%" but, with AI, it can pay to check - so I figured out how to calculate the range:

    I make the Adams/Archer Zone V range of reflectance to be 12.728% to 25.456%, but not exactly right for some reason - I blame Casio ... 👎

    Interestingly, in the similar and contemporary chart by Kodak, middle gray is not in the middle of the similarly-described range of reflectances e.g. "weathered wood" ... nowhere near, in fact ...

    Anybody know how to go half a stop each side of 18? Did AI actually get it right ?!

    zones showing no. in the middle.jpg

    JPG, 13.6 KB, uploaded by xpatUSA on Oct. 11, 2024.